Review: Alchemy of Secrets

Title: Alchemy of Secrets
Publisher: Flatiron Books
Author: Stephanie Garber
Pages: 352pp

Holland St. James is a graduate student in Los Angeles. She loves folklore, urban legends, and old Hollywood — especially old films. And then one day she takes a mysterious class on the myths of Los Angeles, a class that leads her to walk down an alley and ask a question she should not. Then her professor disappears and is replaced by a man she thinks she recognizes, but she can’t remember for certain. And her sister stops returning her phone calls. And a funny old man appears on her doorstep, claiming that Holland’s long-deceased father left her a safety deposit box. And then a phone call: she has until midnight on Halloween to find the mythical Alchemical Heart or she will die ….

Garber is the author of several popular teen fantasy-adventure novels, and Alchemy of Secrets is her first foray into adult publishing. And it’s a doozy. I was pulled in from the first page and kept constantly off-balance as Holland careened around Los Angeles, solving one puzzle after another as the clock ticked-ticked-ticked towards midnight. Normally being off-balance is, well, off-putting to me. But not in this case. Garber skillfully coaxes the reader along, offering the answer to one mystery while dropping three more in our path. The reward for solving one puzzle is another puzzle, keeping the reader’s mind — and heart — engaged.

And this is a mind-bending trip of a book. Garber makes use of every narrative device from present-tense second person interludes to movie scripts to close third-person point of view to tell the story. And it all works, the pieces slipping and sliding together like an old-fashioned Chinese puzzle box. Five chapters in, I was convinced that I knew what was going on. Ten chapters, and I had completely changed my mind. Fifteen chapters and I had another theory. None of them were right.

(No, I’m not going to tell you my ideas. You can have fun coming up with your own.)

Without spoiling too much, I will say that I was completely knocked sideways by the ending, but I also found it thoroughly satisfying.

Well, mostly satisfying. I would have no objection if Garber decided to write more stories set in this fantastical, secretly magical Los Angeles.

Highly recommended to fans of Garber’s other books, as well as The Astral Library by Kate Quinn, The Curse of Penryth Hall by Jess Armstrong, Tales From the Mystic of Sage Street by Alina Lee, and The Amalfi Curse by Sarah Penner.

Leave a Reply